Allison Findlay Key West Realtor | Brenda Donnelly Real Estate logo
Allison Findlay Key West Realtor | Brenda Donnelly Real Estate logo
Allison Findlay Key West Realtor | Brenda Donnelly Real Estate logo

Key West Real Estate, Refined

Buying, selling, and navigating opportunities across Key West and the Lower Keys.

Explore Listings
Start the Conversation
Learn more
Allison Findlay Key West Realtor | Brenda Donnelly Real Estate logo

Search Listings

Enter city, zip, neighborhood, address…
Loading in progress…
No results found
Type in anything you’re looking for
Search

Explore Key West & Lower Keys Communities

From Key West and Stock Island to Big Coppitt Key, Sugarloaf Key, and Old Town, discover the distinct island settings Allison Findlay knows well.

Explore Areas
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/03/ad74bdd5b98b11219b11ab05f58c76ac64dba04b.webp

Key West

In Key West, Florida, USA, the atmosphere is unmistakable: creative, tropical, and deeply connected to the sea. Best for: Buyers seeking a…
View Area
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/03/80408d97ffdfe89249111ec830065261e0c3ef0e.webp

Old Town

Old Town is what most people picture when they think of Key West—historic homes, walkability, and close proximity to Duval Street. It’s one of…
View Area
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/05/c148a40fc450eec4ed3c9d327003909e48f737ca.jpg

Casa Marina

Casa Marina has a quieter, more residential feel with larger lots and close access to the beach. It’s consistently one of the strongest areas for…
View Area
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/03/14de53503bc24c99a57d4a7713e07ac1fb0e01e4.jpg

The Meadows

The Meadows is a quieter pocket just outside Old Town with a mix of historic homes and updated properties. It’s a great option if you want to be…
View Area
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/05/95b06e00c13bb81d26d8e9f8f33c4d42b0530b49.jpg

Midtown

Midtown Key West is a residential neighborhood divided into East and West sections, known for larger lots and classic mid-century homes.
View Area
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/05/a63cf4feddb1e32a6118f3bf99c0bc49c40fab19.jpg

New Town

New Town Key West offers a mix of older and newer homes in a relaxed residential setting away from the crowds of Old Town.
View Area
Explore Areas

Featured Listings

Whether you're buying or selling in Key West, Allison Findlay has the expertise, resources, and dedication to deliver exceptional results. Your journey to finding or marketing your Key West home begins with Key West Luxury Group.
Newly Listed
<p>Featured Listings</p>
Featured
$6,965,000
1101 Casa Marina Court, Key West, FL, 33040
5
5
ACTIVE
MLS# 619169
<p>Featured Listings</p>
Featured
$6,200,000
36 Cannon Royal Drive, Shark Key, FL, 33040
5
5
ACTIVE
MLS# 617894
<p>Featured Listings</p>
Featured
$3,895,000
813 Thomas Street, Key West, FL, 33040
4
3
ACTIVE
MLS# 619706

No results found

Please remove some of the selected filters.
Allison Findlay - Key West Real Estate Agent

Key West Real Estate, Done Strategically

Buying, selling, and identifying opportunities across Key West. I work with clients who value a clear, informed approach—whether securing the right property or positioning one for sale.

More About Allison

Key West Real Estate Blog

Read the Key West Real Estate Blog for market updates, island lifestyle insights, and Lower Keys investment tips from Allison Findlay of Key West Luxury Group.
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/05/5e5a0a10c0a5ce83d400d0b16153dbe3011e4ea1.jpg
Read More
CommunityHistoric HomesKey WestLifestyle

The Key West Art Scene and Why It Shapes Historic Home Buying

The art scene in Key West is not confined to galleries. It lives on front porches, in tropical gardens, along quiet Old Town streets, and in the architecture of the historic homes that define the island’s character.
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/03/afe78f86bda4cb2bc3251bf96e29d00ec362019a.webp
Allison Findlay
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/05/989b271f1c17e101910e73950fd4b5649e319c7c.jpg
Read More
CommunityKey WestLifestyle

Key West Tennis Community: Where Lifestyle and Real Estate Meet

In Key West, lifestyle is shaped as much by daily rituals and relationships as it is by ocean views and historic architecture. Just north of Old Town at Bayview Park, Island City Tennis serves as more than a place to play — it is a gathering place woven into the rhythm of…
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/03/afe78f86bda4cb2bc3251bf96e29d00ec362019a.webp
Allison Findlay
View more

Client Testimonials:

I’m proud to help clients achieve their real estate goals with personalized service and real results. Here’s what they’re saying about working with me.

inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/03/f091f873575c3e68a616a96ddcf5147c94a3c326.webp
Incredible Professionalism And Attention To Detail
Allison handled the sale of our Key West property with incredible professionalism and attention to detail. From pricing to staging to negotiating,…
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/03/95cd704464b98124ffb92e0e7827339acbcb4336.webp
She Was Sharp, Responsive, And Completely Dialed In
Allison brought me an off-market opportunity I wouldn’t have found on my own—a legal transient property that checked every box. Her network is…
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/03/80408d97ffdfe89249111ec830065261e0c3ef0e.webp
We Would Highly Recommend Allison
We worked with Allison recently on the listing and successful sale of our home in Key West. Allison is knowledgeable regarding the local market and…
Read More
inception-app-prod/MTgxOGFiMzktM2NmZC00N2EwLWE4OTMtY2M0NDVkMmI0NmRi/content/2026/05/b2de44676a1cae5f3153a94ea2671458c4901cc7.jpg

Contact Allison Findlay

Contact Allison to discuss Key West and Lower Keys homes, tours, pricing, or next steps with personalized guidance.

Contact Allison Findlay